
There are numerous discussions on this topic and I believe there is no right or wrong answer. The decision lies with the individual and their needs.
I was thinking about this recently as I was getting ready to build a gaming PC in the coming months (mainly in time for Diablo 3 & Starcraft 2). I myself own a PS3 and Wii and am content with them both as they both offer me different experiences. That in itself could spark another discussion on which console is better.
Now in terms of whether the better platform for gaming is PC or consoles, as I mentioned it depends on the individual. I’ve been gaming since I was at least 5 years old and grew up on consoles. I eventually explored PC gaming and instantly took to it as I had a fondness for strategy games. This isn’t to say I abandoned consoles as I would still regularly get together with my friends on the weekends and fire up my consoles.
For me console gaming has always been about getting together with friends and having a good time all sitting together on one TV. This also brings up the issue of cost as not everyone needs to have a console and/or games to be able to share in the experience. Another factor I like is that everyone on a console is on the same playing field in terms of hardware. This also means that a console will become outdated compared to PCs as technology accelerates so quickly these days. Another very important point is that of compatibility. When you buy a game for your console you know it’s going to work without any tweaking or fuss.
PC gaming while it can be a social event with its large communities and LAN parties, for me at least it tends to be a more personal experience. It’s me glued to my screen playing against faceless opponents most of the time and I have no problem with that. Then there is the issue of game genres for example: RTS games lend themselves better to PCs rather than consoles. Some games just suit certain hardware more than others and that’s a fact no matter what some may claim. I mentioned the issue of cost; in my experience PC gaming has always been more expensive as I demand a powerful rig. The initial cost of a good machine and then periodical upgrades can leave a serious dent in the wallet. Games however are cheaper than their console counterparts which works out nicely if your the kind of person who buys a lot of games a year. On top of that PCs can be used for many other things than gaming, so that is a huge consideration when deciding.
I could go on and on discussing the differences between the two gaming platform but my argument is this, go for which you will enjoy the most. Some people don’t have the option to go both routes so it will be one or the other. Gaming is about having fun at the end of the day and there is no point choosing a platform simply because someone else says it is superior.